The professor who made you write your own grading criteria.
THE PROFESSOR WHO MADE YOU WRITE YOUR OWN GRADING CRITERIA.
Follow for more unforgettable "Professor Moments" that shaped our journeys. View More
That first day, the lecture hall hummed with a unique mix of ambition and a touch of the unknown. We’d settled in, clutching our freshly printed syllabi, ready to absorb the wisdom of another brilliant mind. Then, came the curveball – not a pop quiz, but a profound challenge that flipped our entire understanding of academic success on its head.
"This semester," the professor announced, "you will define your own grading criteria." A collective ripple of confusion, then nervous murmurs, spread through the room. Were they serious? After years of meticulously structured evaluations, the idea of dictating our own metrics felt liberating yet terrifying. How do you grade yourself? What if we graded ourselves too leniently? Or, perhaps more terrifyingly, too harshly?
It wasn't a shortcut to an easy A; it was an invitation to ownership. This wasn't about mastering content for a test; it was about truly internalizing the learning, understanding the value of our work, and articulating what excellence looked like for us. We spent weeks wrestling with rubrics, debating the merits of process versus product, qualitative versus quantitative assessment. It forced us to think critically not just about the subject matter, but about the very nature of learning and accountability.
That professor didn't just teach us a discipline; they taught us self-reflection, integrity, and the courage to define our own standards in a world often eager to define them for us. It was an unconventional, even audacious, approach that remains a cornerstone of our most formative university experiences. A true life lesson disguised as an academic exercise.